Military diplomacy has become an integral part of the overall national security planning in the 21st century. While military diplomacy encompasses many approaches, it can involve coercive diplomacy or even a simple exchange of military officers between two states for education and training. Recently, many states have pursued joint military exercises as part of broader military goals.
In recent years, China's proactive involvement in military diplomacy has included joint exercises with many countries, including India, aimed at advancing security cooperation in the Asia-Pacific region. Most recently, China and Pakistan conducted a three-day military exercise codenamed ‘Friendship 2004’ in Taxkorgan Tajik Autonomous County, near Xinjiang province, bordering Afghanistan and Pakistan. Starting on August 4, 2004, the exercise could be one more step in that direction. As conceived, it would help improve their capacity for jointly combating terrorism.
During this exercise, Pakistan and China held joint military maneuvers and drills. More than 200 military officers participated in the exercise. Personnel from the People's Liberation Army (PLA) of China and the Pakistani armed forces practiced both indoor and outdoor procedures, including joint command headquarters and troop drills.
It is the first joint counter-terrorism military exercise between the two countries. Earlier in October 2003, Chinese and Pakistani naval forces conducted a joint search-and-rescue exercise, the first joint exercise since the founding of the People's Republic of China. Interestingly, while China is more preoccupied with building its trade, industry, and social infrastructure and strengthening its economic base, it does not neglect the strategic dimension of the nation-building process. The Chinese 21st-century ‘cultural revolution’ has been trying to balance the state-building process by concentrating on both economic dimensions and military reforms.
However, much more could be read between the lines than the mere rhetoric of military diplomacy and statements like, ‘such drills would help maintain security and stability in the region’. First, the exercise took place near the border with Kashmir. The terrain was rugged, with mountainous ranges and an average altitude of 4000 meters. The exercise used advanced weapons, and live-fire operations were conducted. Successful exchanges of information and methods of organizing combat operations took place. In a way, both the countries that have stakes in Kashmir have practiced on terrain that is very similar to what could be the ‘battlefield of tomorrow ’ if the war erupts between India and Pakistan.
Second, the United States’ war on terrorism has allowed Washington to expand its influence over Pakistan. The US military has thousands of troops stationed in Afghanistan to hunt Al-Qaeda and the Taliban, terrorists. Moreover, the US is covertly exploiting counter-terrorism strategy to promote its strategic interest in the region. According to the latest reports, US forces are unlikely to leave Iraq for at least the next five years. China understands the importance of US forces' presence in the region. At this juncture, China can not lose its ‘all-weather’ friend to the US and would like to engage Pakistan more effectively.
Third, China has frozen the Kashmir issue, not forgotten it. The PLA is concerned about the moral high ground India has attained on this issue. It understands that the ‘engaging India’ policy would not allow the US to help Pakistan overtly on this issue. Pakistan and China are also aware of the recent consolidation of US-India military relations. Against this backdrop, it is likely interested in signaling to Pakistan that China's ‘option’ remains available.
Lastly, China is a key arms supplier to Pakistan. It is a known fact that Pakistan’s nuclear and missile capability is a result of Chinese collaboration. Therefore, a joint exercise could be just an extension of their ‘not so overt’ military policies.
From China’s point of view, however, certain domestic compulsions were evident in choosing the Xinjiang region. This region is dominated by Uighur Muslims seeking an independent East Turkestan. Post 9/11, China has labeled these groups as terrorists. By engaging Pakistan, China is conveying a message to insurgents that they should not expect any support from their Muslim neighbors.
Undoubtedly, Friendship 2004 is likely to strengthen cooperation between the two countries. It is also expected to boost bilateral cooperation in non-traditional security spheres. Nevertheless, India should take note of such exercises, which are highly significant to Pakistan. Exercises like this would undoubtedly enhance their professional capabilities and help shape their future operational philosophy. By engaging both India and Pakistan effectively, China is playing military diplomacy at the core. But then again, everybody knows whose side it will take in case of any eventuality.
Ajey Lele (Ph.D.) is a Research Fellow at the Institute for Defense Studies and Analyses in New Delhi.